Are Older Cars Really Cheaper to Insure in Utah?
Are older cars really cheaper to insure in Utah? Learn how vehicle age, safety features, and coverage choices affect premiums for Salt Lake City drivers.

Its a common belief that the older your car is, the cheaper it is to insure. In many cases, this is truebut there are a few important factors that determine whether your premiums actually drop with an aging vehicle.
For Utah drivers, especially in Salt Lake City, insurance rates depend on much more than just the cars age. Lets break down how insurers calculate rates for older vehicles and whether you can really expect lower costs.
Why Older Cars Often Have Lower Insurance Costs in Utah
The biggest reason older cars tend to be cheaper to insure is their lower market value. Insurance payouts are based on the cars actual cash value (ACV). Since an older car is worth less, the maximum payout for damage or total loss is lower, which reduces the insurers risk.
In addition, many owners of older cars drop collision and comprehensive coverage, sticking only with the state-required liability coverage. This significantly reduces the premium.
It is to find affordable car insurance for older vehicles in Salt Lake Cityif you evaluate the right level of coverage based on your cars current value.
When Older Cars Arent Cheaper to Insure
While older cars usually cost less to cover, there are exceptions. For example:
-
Classic or collectible cars may require special insurance policies that can be more expensive.
-
Poor safety features on older models may increase liability risks.
-
High repair costs for rare or outdated parts can raise premiums.
-
Driving environmentliving in a high-risk area like Salt Lake City with more traffic and theft can offset the age-related savings.
So while a standard aging vehicle generally reduces costs, insurers also look at safety, risk, and repairability.
Should You Drop Full Coverage on an Older Car?
A good rule of thumb is to compare your annual premium for collision and comprehensive coverage to your cars market value. If your car is worth only a few thousand dollars and the full coverage costs nearly as much each year, it might not make financial sense to keep it.
Switching to liability-only insurance on an older car can save a significant amount while still meeting Utahs legal requirements.
Tips to Save Even More on Older Car Insurance
Regardless of your cars age, you can still lower your rates by:
-
Bundling auto insurance with other policies
-
Maintaining a clean driving record
-
Using anti-theft devices
-
Enrolling in a telematics program that rewards safe driving
-
Comparing quotes regularly, as rates change over time
Final Thoughts
In most cases, yesolder cars are cheaper to insure in Utah because of their lower value and reduced need for full coverage. However, factors like safety features, repair costs, and where you live (urban vs. rural) also affect your premium.
For Salt Lake City drivers, its smart to reevaluate your coverage as your car ages to ensure youre not overpaying for unnecessary protection.